Clean People vs. Earth Breeze Laundry Detergent Sheets: 2024 update

Ever felt overwhelmed by the sea of laundry detergents out there? You’re not alone. Today, we’re diving into the world of eco-friendly laundry sheets, specifically comparing Clean People and Earth Breeze.

What are laundry detergent sheets? They’re thin, concentrated sheets of detergent that dissolve in water, replacing bulky liquid or powder detergents.

So, Clean People vs. Earth Breeze: which one comes out on top? We’ll look at:

• Cleaning power
• Eco-friendliness
• Cost-effectiveness
• Convenience

Spoiler alert: While both have their strengths, one edges out the other. But there might be an even better option lurking in the shadows. Intrigued? Let’s dive in!

Clean People vs. Earth Breeze Laundry Detergent Sheets: Complete Guide

As someone who’s been testing laundry products for years, I’ve seen my fair share of hits and misses. I’ve dealt with detergents that left my clothes feeling stiff, others that didn’t quite get the job done, and some that were just plain inconvenient. So, when I heard about laundry detergent sheets, I was intrigued but skeptical. Could these thin sheets really clean as well as traditional detergents?

To answer this question and more, I’ve spent weeks putting Clean People and Earth Breeze laundry sheets through their paces. I’ve washed everything from lightly soiled t-shirts to heavily stained sports uniforms. I’ve tested them in hot and cold water, in standard and HE machines. And now, I’m ready to share my findings with you.

Highlights

Before we dive into the nitty-gritty, let’s take a quick look at some key points:

• Convenience: Clean People takes the lead here. Their sheets come in a sturdy, travel-friendly box with clear instructions. The sheets are perforated, making it easy to use half a sheet for smaller loads.
• Affordability: Earth Breeze wins this round. They offer free shipping on all orders and a 100% money-back guarantee. Their 60-load pack comes in at $0.42 per load, dropping to $0.25 for subscribers.

Now, let’s break down how these two brands stack up against each other in more detail.

Comparing Clean People vs. Earth Breeze

To give you a clear picture, I’ve created a comparison table:

Feature	Clean People	Earth Breeze
Cleaning Power	2.5/5 stars	3.5/5 stars
Ingredients	Paraben-free, Phosphate-free, No added dyes or chlorine bleach	Paraben-free, Phosphate-free, No indication of third-party testing
Vegan & Cruelty-Free	Yes	Yes
Eco-Friendliness	100% plastic-free, Biodegradable packaging, Some plastic in other product packaging	Biodegradable packaging, Carbon-neutral supply chain, Distributed on Amazon (potential for plastic packaging)
Hypoallergenic & Dermatologist Tested	Hypoallergenic	Yes
Scents & Formulas	Fresh Scent, Fragrance Free, Baby	Fresh Scent, Fragrance Free
HE Compatible & Septic Safe	Yes	Yes
Water Compatibility	Hot, Cold, Greywater, Handwashing	Hot, Cold, Greywater, Handwashing
Dissolubility	Good	Good
Price per Load (60ish loads)	$0.47 / 32 loads ($0.40 with subscription)	$0.42 / 60 loads ($0.25 with subscription)
Free Shipping	Yes, for North America	Yes, on all orders
Return Policy	100% money-back guarantee for North America	100% money-back guarantee
Community Outreach	Plants a tree for every 96 Loads Pack ordered	Donates 10 loads of laundry for every pack purchased, We are Neutral partners, 1% for the Planet partners

Now, let’s dive deeper into each brand.

Clean People Overview

Clean People is a San Francisco-based company that’s all about eco-friendly household cleaners. They’re not just about laundry – they’ve got kitchen cleaning products and even a bleach-free stain remover. But today, we’re focusing on their laundry detergent sheets.

Key Features

Clean People’s laundry strips are spongy squares of concentrated detergent. They’re made from biodegradable, plant-based ingredients, which is great news for the environment. These sheets work in both hot and cold water, and they’re compatible with regular and high-efficiency machines.

One thing I particularly liked was their value pack options. For example, you can get a Detergent & Dryer Sheets kit that includes a 96-load box of detergent sheets and a box of fabric softener dryer sheets for $46. It’s a nice way to stock up and save a bit of money.

Pros

1. Discounts for subscribers and bulk purchases
2. 100% plastic-free packaging for laundry sheets
3. Pre-measured, perforated sheets for easy use
4. Dissolves completely in hot or cold water
5. Hypoallergenic formula
6. Plants a tree for every 96-load box sold

Cons

1. Stain removal isn’t as effective as some other brands
2. May need to use more product to get desired clean
3. More expensive than some other laundry sheet brands
4. Uses plastic packaging in some of their other products
5. Free shipping and returns only available for North America

Customer Reviews

Overall, Clean People gets a lot of love from customers. Many people praise the lightweight packaging and how gentle the formula is on sensitive skin. I can attest to this – my easily irritated skin had no issues with these sheets.

However, it’s not all roses. Some reviewers mentioned that the sheets weren’t great on whites or heavily stained laundry. This aligns with my experience – I found myself using more than one sheet on really dirty loads.

A few customers also complained about a strong chemical smell from the Fresh Scent option. I noticed this too, and it was a bit overwhelming for my allergy-prone nose.

Also, read this most interesting related blog: 

Clean People Review: A Complete Test Of Laundry Detergent Sheets

Bottom Line

If you’re looking to do a one-stop shop for eco-friendly cleaning supplies, Clean People could be a good option. Their wide range of products and value packs make it easy to stock up on everything you need. However, when it comes to just laundry detergent sheets, there might be more cost-effective options out there that perform better on tough stains.

Earth Breeze Overview

Earth Breeze is a newer player in the game, founded in 2019 by three friends in Oregon. Their mission? To tackle the massive plastic waste problem in the laundry industry. It’s a noble goal, and one that resonates with many eco-conscious consumers.

Key Features

Like Clean People, Earth Breeze offers spongy sheets of concentrated laundry soap. They dissolve completely in both hot and cold water, mimicking the performance of liquid detergent without the bulky plastic bottle. The sheets are made from plant-based ingredients and are formulated with sensitive skin in mind.

One standout feature of Earth Breeze is their commitment to giving back. For every pack of laundry sheets purchased, they donate 10 loads of laundry to someone in need. They’ve partnered with over 800 organizations to make this happen. Plus, their entire supply chain is carbon neutral. That’s pretty impressive!

Pros

1. Compostable packaging
2. Vegan and animal-friendly formula without harsh chemicals
3. Dissolves completely, even in cold water
4. Hypoallergenic and gentle on skin
5. Travel-friendly
6. Affordable flexible subscription options and free shipping

Cons

1. Delivered wrapped in plastic when ordered from Amazon
2. Paper packaging is easily breakable
3. Not as effective on tough stains
4. Strips are not pre-cut
5. May need to use more than one sheet for heavily soiled loads
6. Scent may be disappointing for those who prefer strongly scented laundry

Customer Reviews

Earth Breeze has garnered quite a few positive reviews. Many customers love the flexible subscription options and report that the sheets work well on average loads of laundry.

However, it’s not all smooth sailing. Some reviewers mentioned finding sticky, white residue on their clothes or in their washing machines. While I didn’t experience this myself, it’s worth noting. If you decide to try Earth Breeze, I’d recommend placing the sheet directly on the laundry drum before adding clothes, just to be safe.

Another common complaint was about the “60-load” claim. Many customers found they needed to use a full sheet even for medium-sized loads to get their clothes clean. This could make the product less cost-effective than it initially appears.

Also, read more interesting related blog: 

My Earth Breeze Review: Can These Laundry Detergent Sheets Stand Up To The Test?

Bottom Line

Earth Breeze is a solid contender in the eco-friendly laundry detergent market. Their biodegradable packaging and vegan, cruelty-free formula tick a lot of boxes for environmentally conscious consumers. The flexible subscription options and free global shipping make them one of the more affordable options out there.

However, the lack of perforated sheets can be inconvenient, and you might end up using more product than you initially planned due to the mild cleaning power. It’s a trade-off between eco-friendliness and cleaning power that each consumer will need to weigh for themselves.

Clean People vs. Earth Breeze: Who Wins?

Now that we’ve looked at each brand individually, let’s pit them against each other in key categories.

Cleaning Power

• Clean People: 2.5/5 stars 
• Earth Breeze: 3.5/5 stars

In my tests, both brands dissolved completely in hot and cold water and worked in all types of washing machines. However, when it came to stain removal, Earth Breeze had a clear edge.

I put both products through their paces with some tough stains – tomato sauce, olive oil, and red wine (hazards of my Italian family dinners!). Earth Breeze did a noticeably better job on these stubborn stains. Clean People, on the other hand, struggled even with some average stains.

It’s worth noting that neither brand performed as well as some traditional detergents on really tough stains. If you’re dealing with a lot of heavily soiled items, you might need to pre-treat or use more than one sheet.

Environmental Impact

• Clean People: 3.5/5 stars 
• Earth Breeze: 4/5 stars

Both Clean People and Earth Breeze are making significant strides in reducing plastic waste, water waste, and carbon emissions in the laundry industry. Their sheet format cuts down on packaging and eliminates the need to ship water-heavy liquid detergents. Both companies also have eco-conscious initiatives, like tree planting and partnerships with environmental organizations.

However, there are some issues with packaging for both brands. Earth Breeze arrived wrapped in plastic when I ordered from Amazon (though this may not be the case when ordering directly from their website). The paper envelope was also quite fragile – I can see it potentially tearing during shipping or storage.

Clean People’s laundry sheet packaging is recyclable cardboard, which is great. However, some of their other products still come in recycled plastic packaging. Also, the box of sheets comes in yet another box, which feels a bit wasteful.

Earth Breeze edges out Clean People here due to their carbon-neutral supply chain and more consistent eco-friendly packaging across their product line.

Ingredients and Formulas

• Clean People: 4/5 stars 
• Earth Breeze: 5/5 stars

Both brands performed well in terms of gentleness. My sensitive skin had no issues with either product, and our clothes felt soft and comfortable after washing. Both formulas are hypoallergenic, vegan, cruelty-free, and made from plant-based, biodegradable ingredients.

Earth Breeze takes the lead here because their formula is dermatologist-tested. While Clean People’s sheets are formulated for sensitive skin, they don’t make this claim. Additionally, I found Clean People’s fresh scent to be quite strong and almost chemical-smelling, which could be an issue for those with sensitivities or allergies.

Cost-Effectiveness

• Clean People: 3/5 stars 
• Earth Breeze: 4.5/5 stars

When it comes to price, Earth Breeze is the clear winner. Let’s break it down:

Clean People:

• 32-load box: $0.40 per load with subscription
• 96-load box: $0.29 per load with subscription

Earth Breeze:

• 60-load pack: $0.25 per load with subscription

Both companies offer flexible subscription options. Clean People allows you to receive deliveries every one to three months, while Earth Breeze offers one to four-month intervals. Clean People offers a 15% discount for subscribers, while Earth Breeze offers up to 40% off.

It’s important to note that these calculations assume you’ll use half a sheet per load. In reality, you might find yourself using a full sheet more often than not, especially with Clean People’s less effective formula. This could significantly increase your per-load cost.

Convenience

• Clean People: 4.5/5 stars 
• Earth Breeze: 4.5/5 stars

Both brands offer the inherent convenience of laundry sheets – they’re travel-friendly, pre-measured, and less messy than liquid detergents. However, there are some small differences:

Clean People’s packaging is sturdier and easier to open and close. Their sheets are also perforated, making it simple to use half a sheet for smaller loads. However, the box is bulkier for storage.

Earth Breeze’s packaging is more compact, but the sheets aren’t pre-cut. They do offer a handy store locator page if you prefer to buy in person.

In the end, I rated them equally on convenience, as the pros and cons balance out.

Why We Recommend HeySunday Instead

After extensive testing of various laundry sheet brands, including Clean People and Earth Breeze, I’ve found that HeySunday laundry detergent sheets consistently come out on top for my family.

Here’s why:

1. Value for Money: HeySunday sheets are competitively priced at $0.23 per load for subscribers, making them even more affordable than Earth Breeze.
2. Pre-divided Sheets: Unlike Earth Breeze, HeySunday sheets are pre-divided, combining the convenience of Clean People’s perforated sheets with Earth Breeze’s compact packaging.
3. Powerful Formula: HeySunday’s formula is strong enough that one sheet is usually sufficient for medium-sized loads, and two for heavily soiled items. This reliability ensures you’re not using more product than necessary.
4. Gentle on Skin: As someone with sensitive skin, I appreciate that HeySunday sheets are incredibly gentle without compromising on cleaning power.
5. Eco-Friendly Packaging: HeySunday has eliminated excess packaging with their slim envelope design, further reducing environmental impact.
6. Transparent Ingredients: After researching numerous laundry detergents, I can confidently say that HeySunday’s formula stands up to leading brands like Tru Earth and Earth Breeze in terms of clean, effective ingredients.

While Clean People and Earth Breeze both have their strengths, HeySunday manages to combine the best aspects of both – the convenience and eco-friendliness of laundry sheets with powerful cleaning and skin-friendly formulas.

Clean People vs. Earth Breeze Final Thoughts

After putting both Clean People and Earth Breeze through their paces, Earth Breeze emerges as the winner in this head-to-head comparison. They edge out Clean People in cleaning power, environmental impact, and cost-effectiveness.

That said, both companies are making commendable efforts in the eco-friendly laundry space. Clean People offers a wider range of products, which might appeal to those looking to overhaul their entire cleaning routine. Earth Breeze, on the other hand, focuses solely on laundry but does it well.

Ultimately, the choice between these two (or any other brand) will depend on your specific needs and priorities. Do you need something that’s gentle on sensitive skin? Are you dealing with lots of tough stains? Is budget your primary concern? Or are you looking for the most eco-friendly option possible?

Remember, switching to laundry detergent sheets is already a big step towards a more environmentally friendly home. Whether you choose Clean People, Earth Breeze, or another brand like HeySunday, you’re making a positive impact.

As you embark on your eco-friendly laundry journey, don’t be afraid to experiment. What works best for me might not be the perfect solution for you. Try out different brands, pay attention to how they perform on your typical laundry loads, and see how they affect your skin and your wallet.

And don’t forget – laundry habits matter too! Using cold water when possible, only washing full loads, and air-drying when you can all contribute to a more eco-friendly laundry routine.

I’d love to hear about your experiences with these or other laundry detergent sheets. Have you tried Clean People or Earth Breeze? What did you think? Or maybe you’ve found another brand that you swear by? Share your thoughts in the comments below. Your insights could help other readers find their perfect laundry solution!

Remember, every load of laundry is an opportunity to make a small but meaningful difference for our planet. Here’s to fresher, cleaner clothes and a healthier Earth!

Read more related interesting blogs

Shark Vs. Dyson: Which Vacuum Brand Truly Sucks (In A Good Way)?

Can You Mix Fabuloso And Bleach?

What Is Non-Detergent Soap?